yop Moderator
#121

Spanish Johnny said:
Am I right in saying the Inter County players picked the Player and Young Player of the Years as opposed to the Journalists with the All Stars?

Just makes it interesting as I think you need to respect fellow player verdicts than journalists.


Well that makes total sense if they do. Journos dont have a bean.

Nialler15 Registered User
#122

Spanish Johnny said:
Am I right in saying the Inter County players picked the Player and Young Player of the Years as opposed to the Journalists with the All Stars?

Just makes it interesting as I think you need to respect fellow player verdicts than journalists.



I agree with you...and as I asked above was it a sign of how much Gaelic football has changed?

Spanish Johnny Registered User
#123

Nialler15 said:
I agree with you...and as I asked above was it a sign of how much Gaelic football has changed?


Yes I believe it does. I don't think it can be exclusively put down to certain journalists pushing a certain agenda/cause now. I think players give an honest enough reflection and I think Gaelic Football has certainly changed right down to the players opinion of what makes the difference, etc...

Nothing against Michael Dara but I am a more Brogan, Gooch, Cavanagh type winner..

yop Moderator
#124

Spanish Johnny said:
Yes I believe it does. I don't think it can be exclusively put down to certain journalists pushing a certain agenda/cause now. I think players give an honest enough reflection and I think Gaelic Football has certainly changed right down to the players opinion of what makes the difference, etc...

Nothing against Michael Dara but I am a more Brogan, Gooch, type winner Cavanagh type rugby player..


IFTFU

Spanish Johnny Registered User
#125

yop said:
IFTFU


Still a class footballer!

I am a fan of the US MVP system.

I think there is a difference between MVP and Man of the Match/Player of the Year.

I cite 2001 as an example with Galway.

Declan Meehan was unbelievable that year. I may be wrong but I think everyone of his direct opponents were substituted that year bar one possibly?

Padraig Joyce was excellent at times and quiet at others. His final performance summed up his year. First half not his best then he comes out and basically wins the All Ireland for Galway.

Now on balance in terms of consistency and excellence of performance you cant argue with Meehan. But turn it around - who are you more likely to have won without?? Probably Meehan too in that you could replace a wing back to good effect but would you ever compensate for Joyce's loss or match his contribution??

That's just my take. Through that prism you would have to give the All Ireland winners Player of the Year every year and maybe this year Cluxton was the MVP or Brogan??

1 person has thanked this post
ciarriaithuaidh Registered User
#126

McAuley had a huge effect on Dublin's success this year and deserves his award IMO.

He isn't the most skillful or graceful, but his strength and commitment are top notch. He dominated Aidan O'Sé in the final, was probably the most effective midfielder overall in the Kerry game (although Maher had a good first half) and despite the fact that players know now he is going to carry the ball, he doesn't get dispossesed often.

I would have liked to see Gooch get it being biased, but not going to quibble with that choice to be fair.

2 people have thanked this post
MaroonAndGreen Registered User
#127

From a Mayo perspective, I think Ger Cafferkey and Cillian O'Connor will be desperately disappointed not to have received an All-Star.

O'Connor's omission is strange IMO, the man scored 6 goals in the championship, 3 of those in the game where Mayo beat the reigning champions! Even stranger is that he didnt win YPOTY!

3 people have thanked this post
dcr22B Registered User
#128

MaroonAndGreen said:
O'Connor's omission is strange IMO, the man scored 6 goals in the championship, 3 of those in the game where Mayo beat the reigning champions! Even stranger is that he didnt win YPOTY!
It isn't really when you think about it:

- he scored 6 goals against London (hardly world beaters, no disrespect) and a Donegal team that were in a mess (two of them were tap ins also)

-he didn't score enough from play or influence a game enough when it counted (although he wasn't really aided by a misfiring forward line in general in the final)

- Jack was much more consistent all year even if he did fade towards the end of the year (something he will no doubt be aware of himself and will work on over the winter)

Cillian won't let missing out on an All Star bother him too much. What will bother him is that there doesn't seem to forwards coming through in Mayo that are the difference between finally breaking that long wait for Sam and forever being the bridesmaid.

DDC1990 Registered User
#129

dcr22B said:
It isn't really when you think about it:

- he scored 6 goals against London (hardly world beaters, no disrespect) and a Donegal team that were in a mess (two of them were tap ins also)

-he didn't score enough from play or influence a game enough when it counted (although he wasn't really aided by a misfiring forward line in general in the final)

- Jack was much more consistent all year even if he did fade towards the end of the year (something he will no doubt be aware of himself and will work on over the winter)

Cillian won't let missing out on an All Star bother him too much. What will bother him is that there doesn't seem to forwards coming through in Mayo that are the difference between finally breaking that long wait for Sam and forever being the bridesmaid.


I don't know how you can say McCaffrey was more consistent. He was a liability in the Semi Final and Final. He was great against Cork and good against Meath, but I couldn't for a second say he was consistent.

O'Connor when injury permitted him to be on the field played very well. He missed two frees in the AIF which he played half fit, and still kicked all the frees from then on. He might not have played brilliantly but he didn't play poorly either.

Whether he was an All Star is questionable. McManus had a fine year as did O'Donaghue but I think he certainly should have been YPOY.

MDMA fully deserved the POTY award and though I would have liked to see Gooch nominated, McAuley had such a huge influence on this Dublin team everytime he was on the field.

5 people have thanked this post
seligehgit Registered User
#130

Agreed re the changing nature of football and arguments for and against rewarding the finesse players versus the undervalued so called workhorses who are less skillful.But for somebody whose admiration of the Gooch knows no boundaries,how can you award him Player of the Year for a first half of sustained brilliance and a good year besides by his elevated standards?All Ireland final winners usually pick up the gong,MDMA was'nt outstanding in the All Ireland final but certainly the Dublin midfield's mobility helped in the winning of that final.His will to win that ball and put his body on the line against the 3 Kerry lads went a long way towards Dublin recapturing Sam.
MDMA was consistently good this year and as was mentioned before Dublin's biggest mistake in last year's All Ireland semi final was starting him against us at centre forward,the pendulum swung back when he was switched back to midfield.

1 person has thanked this post
Stoner Moderator
#131

So general consensus, MDMA deserved it.

COC should have picked up the YPOTY.

7 people have thanked this post
dcr22B Registered User
#132

DDC1990 said:
I don't know how you can say McCaffrey was more consistent. He was a liability in the Semi Final and Final. He was great against Cork and good against Meath, but I couldn't for a second say he was consistent.
Did you actually read the third point of my post?

Spanish Johnny Registered User
#133

Stoner said:
So general consensus, MDMA deserved it.

COC should have picked up the YPOTY.


On performance yes probably but he will manage with two of them in fairness. Probably a lot more annoyed about the All Star.

DDC1990 Registered User
#134

dcr22B said:
Did you actually read the third point of my post?


Yes, and I have no idea how a player who plays well in some games and terrible in others can be defined as consistent.

Consistency implies playing at the same level over the whole year.

In my opinion he was the opposite of consistant.

dcr22B Registered User
#135

Nice of you to nitpick like that when I acknowledged that he struggled in the last two games of the year

Want to share your thoughts?

Login here to discuss!