MadsL Registered User
#1

I'm suprised to see adverts allowing homeopathic products.

http://www.adverts.ie/for-sale/q_homeopathic/

Are these not covered by the list of forbidden items?

Some items that may not be sold include: Stocks and securities, lottery tickets, illicit drugs, prescriptive devices and drugs

Prescription drugs and medical devices. Please note that the Medicinal Products (Prescription and Control of Supply) Regulations expressly prohibit the supply of any medicinal product, no matter which category it's in, by mail order. Furthermore, the Regulations define mail order so as to include the use of electronic means to transmit an order. Even a pharmacy or a pharmacist can't sell through the internet in this country.


So drugs that actually work are banned, but adverts sells 'magic pills'? Interesting.

1 person has thanked this post
Lazarus2.0 Adverts.ie Moderator
#2

Medicinal Products (Prescription and Control of Supply) Regulations 2003 makes the distinction .

MadsL said:

So drugs that actually work are banned, but adverts sells 'magic pills'?

You also make the distinction .

And your argument is that Adverts shouldn't make the distinction ?


I dont necessarily disagree that some or maybe even all homeopathic products should be forbidden but if you want Admins to consider it (which I'm sure they will anyway) I cant help thinking a more cohesive argument would help your cause more than your OP .

* Note - pharmacy vs homeopathy is irrelevant here . Pharmaceutical products are prohibited from sale on Adverts by law .

Tigger Registered User
#3

It's water or sugar pills with drops of water on them

So let the fools be parted from their money

#4

Homeopathic drugs are classed as organic... Their is no law on the sale of them,

but yet the EU want to ban 90% of the drugs.

partyatmygaff Registered User
#5

Cork24 said:
Homeopathic drugs are classed as organic... Their is no law on the sale of them,

but yet the EU want to ban 90% of the drugs.

How are they "organic"? It's just water and a bit of sugar (Which is "organic" only in the sense it contains carbon).

Tbh, they don't really fall under the category of drugs. Bottled water and beverages maybe.

foggy_lad Banned
#6

Many of them carry warnings about pregnant women using them or children, I don't know squat about them but would think that they could contain absolutely anything much like head shop drugs which are banned so in my humble opinion anything that is seen as medicinal should be banned.

partyatmygaff Registered User
#7

foggy_lad said:
Many of them carry warnings about pregnant women using them or children, I don't know squat about them but would think that they could contain absolutely anything much like head shop drugs which are banned so in my humble opinion anything that is seen as medicinal should be banned.

Why would they add chemicals? Chemicals cost money. Water is free.

1 person has thanked this post
mcmoustache Registered User
#8

I'm thinking about getting in on the action.

I have a source of homeopathic medicines in my kitchen which should cover just about everything. In fact, I can even concoct a homeopathic treatment for stab-wounds by dipping a knife into a solution.


Seriously, what's to stop me from doing this and cluttering adverts.ie up with nonsense besides my conscience?

mcmoustache Registered User
#9

foggy_lad said:
Many of them carry warnings about pregnant women using them or children


That's just to make them look like they might be effective. I'd like to see the study that shows homeopathic "medicine" is dangerous for pregnant women. As much as I hate homeopathy, it's perfectly safe and has almost no side effects. The solutions and pills contain nothing but water or sugars.

campo Registered User
#10

have to admit bought the teething gradual for my 10 month old and they were a life saver

MadsL Registered User
#11

campo said:
have to admit bought the teething gradual for my 10 month old and they were a life saver


Yet some of the preparations for teething contain Belladonna - a poison taken in large enough doses. Of course, at homeopathic levels there is about a 1 in 10000 chance that there is a molecule of Belladona in them.

I cant help thinking a more cohesive argument would help your cause more than your OP .


OK, is adverts comfortable with sellers selling sugar pills on the basis that they will cure a medical condition, especially when the products listed are aimed at children and recently pregnant women.

I could not sell tested and regulated paracetamol to cure your headache on adverts, yet someone could sell some water with some remote possibility of an 'active ingredient' in it to cure whatever you are having yourself.

I find that hard to swallow (pun intended)

Do you really think that you should allow this type of charlatanism on boards? The inconsistency is ridiculous - you cannot give medical advice on boards.ie but I can cure you on adverts??

I'd appreciate the admins considering this more carefully, I'm cooking up a batch of snake oil at the moment.

2 people have thanked this post
MadsL Registered User
#12

Tigger said:
So let the fools be parted from their money


And the fools are giving them to their kids in place of medical attention.

1 person has thanked this post
foggy_lad Banned
#13

MadsL said:
Yet some of the preparations for teething contain Belladonna - a poison taken in large enough doses. Of course, at homeopathic levels there is about a 1 in 10000 chance that there is a molecule of Belladona in them.


OK, is adverts comfortable with sellers selling sugar pills on the basis that they will cure a medical condition, especially when the products listed are aimed at children and recently pregnant women.

I could not sell tested and regulated paracetamol to cure your headache on adverts, yet someone could sell some water with some remote possibility of an 'active ingredient' in it to cure whatever you are having yourself.

I find that hard to swallow (pun intended)

Do you really think that you should allow this type of charlatanism on boards? The inconsistency is ridiculous - you cannot give medical advice on boards.ie but I can cure you on adverts??

I'd appreciate the admins considering this more carefully, I'm cooking up a batch of snake oil at the moment.

Don't know if it will turn out to be Snake oil but you've certainly opened up a can of worms

1 person has thanked this post
MadsL Registered User
#14

10:23 Campaign against Boots selling Homeopathic 'remedies"

Mass 'overdose'.

muffler Moderator
#15

partyatmygaff said:
Water is free.
Try telling that to Phil Hogan

Want to share your thoughts?

Login here to discuss!