#16

No.

If we win today and maintain the level of performance over the next few games, yes.

Higher Banned
#17

No to be honest. If we win today it only confirms to me that this team has regressed to only winning the odd miracle game but losing consistently.

I really don't know how anyone could defend Kidney when looking at his win/loss ratio of the last 2 years. Its disgraceful.

But, but Kidney won a grand slam........Clive Woodward won a world cup but when he regressed as a coach he was given the boot. Kidney is a poor coach, time to go. The sad truth is that if he wasn't so beloved down in Munster he'd be on his way out. He has strong support from the Munster contingent both inside and outside the IRFU. However I have yet to find one supporter from Leinster/Ulster/Connacht who thinks he should stay.

1 person has thanked this post
cork exile in london Registered User
#18

Higher said:
No to be honest. If we win today it only confirms to me that this team has regressed to only winning the odd miracle game but losing consistently.

I really don't know how anyone could defend Kidney when looking at his win/loss ratio of the last 2 years. Its disgraceful.

But, but Kidney won a grand slam........Clive Woodward won a world cup but when he regressed as a coach he was given the boot. Kidney is a poor coach, time to go. The sad truth is that if he wasn't so beloved down in Munster he'd be on his way out. He has strong support from the Munster contingent both inside and outside the IRFU. However I have yet to find one supporter from Leinster/Ulster/Connacht who thinks he should stay.


Probably the worst wum i seen on here and that takes some doing. munster fans all want kidney as irish coach? my hole they do.

Higher Banned
#19

cork exile in london said:
Probably the worst wum i seen on here and that takes some doing. munster fans all want kidney as irish coach? my hole they do.


Well the only people I see defending him on internet forums and in the media all conveniently have a soft spot for Munster.

Cpt_Blackbeard Registered User
#20

Higher said:
Well the only people I see defending him on internet forums and in the media all conveniently have a soft spot for Munster.


And all the supporters who are gung ho to see him cast aside conveniently have a soft spot for Leinster...

Seriously though, are you capable of posting something that isn't clearly based on a LvM rivalry? You're making me feel/look like an objective and balanced poster ffs.

6 people have thanked this post
sting60 Banned
#21

I would love to know who actually suggested O Sullivan and Kidney.I have a bad feeling about today with Murray,Sexton,Earls and darcy a hugh concern.Hope DOC does not give away penalties.

#22

Cpt_Blackbeard said:
And all the supporters who are gung ho to see him cast aside conveniently have a soft spot for Leinster...


If Ulster and Connacht fans have a soft spot for Leinster, that's their choice!

1 person has thanked this post
#23

Cpt_Blackbeard said:
And all the supporters who are gung ho to see him cast aside conveniently have a soft spot for Leinster...

I think you'll find (if you go back that far) that most people were in favour of Kidney taking over the job regardless of whether they were Munster, Leinster, Connacht or Ulster supporters; myself included.

He started very well with the 09 grand slam but since then and especially in the 6N there have been very few highlights. EOS' head was being called for in spite of better overall win percentages than Kidney has acheived.

When three of our four provinces are into the knockout stages of the HEC, the contrast to the performance of the national team couldn't be more stark. It's also an accumulation of small but worrying trends such as not replacing the backs coach, ignoring form players (and I include form Munster and Ulster players in this) and a gameplan that appears to be going against the grain of the selected players.

1 person has thanked this post
Higher Banned
#24

Cpt_Blackbeard said:
And all the supporters who are gung ho to see him cast aside conveniently have a soft spot for Leinster...

Seriously though, are you capable of posting something that isn't clearly based on a LvM rivalry? You're making me feel/look like an objective and balanced poster ffs.


Are you serious? Look at Ulster forums opinion of Kidney or better yet ask some Connacht supporters on here if they think Kidney should go.

If you honestly think that ALL the supporters who want Kidney to go are from Leinster then it is you who is posting based on LvM rivalry not me.

irishbucsfan Registered User
#25

NOW I DON'T KNOW HOW TO FEEL ABOUT ANYTHING

6 people have thanked this post
#26

Cpt_Blackbeard said:
And all the supporters who are gung ho to see him cast aside conveniently have a soft spot for Leinster...


Or Ulster, or Connacht, or Munster...

CatFromHue Moderator
#27

irishbucsfan said:
NOW I DON'T KNOW HOW TO FEEL ABOUT ANYTHING


I'd be the same as I was before the game to be honest. At the end of the 6 Nations I think is the best time to look back at how the team and management have done.

TiltedBrain Registered User
#28

I CANT BELIEVE THERE WAS NO DRAW OPTION IN THE POLL

Leinster7 Registered User
#29

France were poor in the first half. Ireland played well up until half time. They choked it in the 2nd half. Kidney is still not good enough. Needs to be a change post 6N if Ireland are to have any chance of winning the next RWC.

#30

Leinster7 said:
France were poor in the first half. Ireland played well up until half time. They choked it in the 2nd half. Kidney is still not good enough. Needs to be a change post 6N if Ireland are to have any chance of winning the next RWC.

France were surprised in the first half by our use of the rush defense. Nothing in our previous outings would have suggested we'd be using it and they got caught flat footed. They responded in the second half once PSA had a chance to react to it and of course we had no plan B to change things up once the element of surprise was lost.

The weather and Pearson didn't help either, but when you've no attacking game plan, you can't rely on opposition mistakes for a full match.

Want to share your thoughts?

Login here to discuss!