#46

firkin said:
Actually having read that thread you posted thats where I got my info from. You yourself posted that Group B was for DTT.


That link you posted clearly recommends Group B for DTT.


The point I'm making (and I think your post has proved) is RTE NL's communication is dire and needs fixing. I don't think you can argue with that?


I recommended a Wideband actually.

http://www.boards.ie/vbulletin/showpost.php?p=70067279&postcount=8

I dont disagree that it is a bit of a mess though.

1 person has thanked this post
The Cush Registered User
#47

firkin said:
I can't believe to this day they still have that misleading and seriously deficient document on the web site.

There's no excuse for it. It would take 5 mins to annotate that PDF and upload it to their web site.

Its either incompetence or laziness or both.


In my opinion it may be neither, more likely international coordination with the UK (Ofcom) hadn't been completed but with the information on the retunes now released the DTT plan may now be finalised. I would expect the DTT frequency guide to be published in due course if this is the case.

firkin said:
From the tit-for-tat replies you were giving me I thought you were on their side. Glad to hear we're on the same page


I'm not on anyone's side but my own and post based on information in the public domain.

1 person has thanked this post
#48

The Cush said:
I posted that information from the Comreg source document here a few weeks ago.

The thing is that information is the Comreg licensed max coordinted ERPs for each of the sites but may not be the actual ERP used for the sites by RTÉNL. If you compare the analogue information from the document with the actual RTÉNL information there can be a difference.

We don't know the actual ERPs until RTÉNL publish the information similar to the analogue frequency list.


Wasnt aware that it had been posted it previously.

But yeah they are the maximum licensed ERPs. RTE will be using the max in those cases, but not in all cases right now as they have analogue Txs operating in tandom from a number of towers. Come ASO there will be significant power increases IMO.

firkin Registered User
#49



Ahh, you may have recommended wideband but RTE NL didn't.

STB said:

I dont disagree that it is a bit of a mess though.


And that's my point exactly

The Cush Registered User
#50

STB said:
But yeah they are the maximum licensed ERPs. RTE will be using the max in those cases, but not in all cases right now as they have analogue Txs operating in tandom from a number of towers. Come ASO there will be significant power increases IMO.


According to RTÉNL at a pre launch Saorview trade event in Apr(?) almost all DTT sites are at full power except those with NI overspill until ASO. But we don't know what ERP they're at until they publish the information.

firkin Registered User
#51

The Cush said:
In my opinion it may be neither, more likely international coordination with the UK (Ofcom) hadn't been completed but with the information on the retunes now released the DTT plan may now be finalised. I would expect the DTT frequency guide to be published in due course if this is the case.


It's no excuse for not amending that "television frequencies" PDF with a simple health warning that the freqencies are for Analogue TV and DTT is different but due to international coordination issues with the UK we cant post the DTT frequencies until some time in the future [or whatever the reason]


The Cush said:

I'm not on anyone's side but my own

Here, here

The Cush Registered User
#52

firkin said:
Ahh, you may have recommended wideband but RTE NL didn't.


RTÉNL recommended a wideband aerial in the Receiving DTT brochure in Apr 2009 for reception of both analogue and DTT from Mt Leinster.

Gerry Wicklow Registered User
#53

@ firkin
i think by now the general consensus is that there has been nothing but inaccurate, misleading and inadequate information from RTÉ / RTÉnl and their various spokespeople/ experts (Gay Byrne, Pat Kenny etc). Considering the way they dug their heels in with the mess in Mt Leinster, it's about all we can expect from them

1 person has thanked this post
firkin Registered User
#54

The Cush said:
RTÉNL recommended a wideband aerial in the Receiving DTT brochure in Apr 2009 for reception of both analogue and DTT from Mt Leinster.


I was specifically replying to:
STB said:
Firkin,

RTE NL have always advised a Wideband aerial for Mt Leinster. It has come up before. My post here with the picture is from the Saorview Aerial guide for consumers.
http://www.boards.ie/vbulletin/showpost.php?p=70069197&postcount=14


That table doesn't recomend wideband for DTT. It recommends Group B for DTT or wideband for Analogue and DTT combined.

I have no idea where you came across that "Receiving DTT brochure in Apr 2009". I certainly never saw it.

firkin Registered User
#55

Gerry Wicklow said:
@ firkin
i think by now the general consensus is that there has been nothing but inaccurate, misleading and inadequate information from RTÉ / RTÉnl and their various spokespeople/ experts (Gay Byrne, Pat Kenny etc). Considering the way they dug their heels in with the mess in Mt Leinster, it's about all we can expect from them


Consensus !! Not by the way The Cush keeps popping off the replies

mrdtv2010 Registered User
#56

Sanity prevails at last in the Mount Leinster/Preseli standoff. Shame it hadn't been thought through from the start: it was obvious that the DTT coverage would match the analogue coverage given the efficiencies of COFDM systems at 7dB below peak analogue ERPs.
On an incidental note the change of the Mount Leinster frequencies will remove any CCI between Mount Leinster and Kilkeel post DSO which is 39, 42 and 45. I see from DUK's site its being reengineered today.

egal Registered User
#57

I refer to post #38.

I notice a big difference in the powers of PSB 01 and PSB 02 from Clermont. Why is that?

The Cush Registered User
#58

egal said:
I notice a big difference in the powers of PSB 01 and PSB 02 from Clermont. Why is that?


Asked here previously also, typo?

Ambp Registered User
#59

What's labeled as RTÉ Pulse is currently picking up RTÉ Radio 1, retuned and still having the same problem

Sponge Bob Banned
#60

The Cush said:
I posted that information from the Comreg source document here a few weeks ago.

There are 60 transmitters there Cush ( counting 2 x Bantry as 1) , when did they start rolling out more of them...by the way the new ones seem to be PSB1 only, eg Timoleague and Greenore. ???

Want to share your thoughts?

Login here to discuss!