#16

thelongfellow said:
Really-you got two accounts?

Nice hatement about Harrington. Any chance you can throw in some facts to back it up? Maybe compare his year to Rose/Casey like others have done and then realise that Harrington has better results this year than Casey and similar ones to Rose).


so harrington has better results this year than Casey does he ?

Harrington /casey
Events played--------------- 17/14
Cuts made --------------------12/11
1st ---------------------------0/0
2nd---------------------------0/1
3rd----------------------------1/1
Top 5 ------------------------5/5
Top 10 ------------------------7/10
Prize Money ------------------- $1,381,453/$2,414,694
Fed Ex -------------------------57th/23rd

you still think harrington has better results than Casey ?

#17

Dr.Silly said:
so harrington has better results this year than Casey does he ?

Harrington /casey
Events played--------------- 17/14
Cuts made --------------------12/11
1st ---------------------------0/0
2nd---------------------------0/1
3rd----------------------------1/1
Top 5 ------------------------5/5
Top 10 ------------------------7/10
Prize Money ------------------- $1,381,453/$2,414,694
Fed Ex -------------------------57th/23rd

you still think harrington has better results than Casey ?


PGA Tour is it? What about the European tour?

In the five months from 1 April to 31 August, Padraig Harrington has played in 14 events and had 6 top 10 finishes. Paul Casey has had only 1 top 10 in 12 events


So based on current form-yes it's pretty obvious his results have been better than Casey.

#18

thelongfellow said:
PGA Tour is it? What about the European tour?


So based on current form-yes it's pretty obvious his results have been better than Casey.

casey

Tour Rankings


PositionNo. of eventsMoney WonEuropean Tour1012€ 1,438,864


harrington

Tour Rankings


PositionNo. of eventsMoney WonEuropean Tour189€ 983,155


Stats are Stats buddy, and it's obviously clear that for 2010, we won't even talk about RyderCup stats, that Harrington is definetely the better form player

#19

Dr.Silly said:
casey

Tour Rankings


PositionNo. of eventsMoney WonEuropean Tour1012€ 1,438,864


harrington

Tour Rankings


PositionNo. of eventsMoney WonEuropean Tour189€ 983,155


Stats are Stats buddy, and it's obviously clear that for 2010, we won't even talk about RyderCup stats, that Harrington is definetely the better form player


Only reason Casey is so high on the money list is his second place in the Open-his only top 10 in nearly 6 months. Lets compare that to Harrington...

You like stats when you think they work for you. Pity that yours don't.

#20

thelongfellow said:
Only reason Casey is so high on the money list is his second place in the Open-his only top 10 in nearly 6 months. Lets compare that to Harrington...

You like stats when you think they work for you. Pity that yours don't.


we haven't even taken into account caseys injury, what injury has harrington had, apart from his mental state.

http://www.skysports.com/story/0,19528,12177_6348225,00.html

this interview is so so true

#21

Dr.Silly said:
we haven't even taken into account caseys injury, what injury has harrington had, apart from his mental state.

http://www.skysports.com/story/0,19528,12177_6348225,00.html

this interview is so so true


HAHA good lad-I thought you were being serious for a few posts there.

#22

thelongfellow said:
HAHA good lad-I thought you were being serious for a few posts there.



ah, blinded by patriotism, good man

DH2K9 Registered User
#23

At the end of the day the question is who can perform on the big day and that is why Monty had to go with Harrington. No matter how he plays sky will still be complaining especially Rob Lee who thank god won't be commentating on the ryder cup, I can't stand him.

#24

DH2K9 said:
At the end of the day the question is who can perform on the big day and that is why Monty had to go with Harrington. No matter how he plays sky will still be complaining especially Rob Lee who thank god won't be commentating on the ryder cup, I can't stand him.


Best way to watch it is without that commentary and just the natural sounds from the course i.e LIVE!

6 top 10's in the past few months and still there are other players with worse stats who should be ahead of him-Harrington was guaranteed a pick compared to Casey based on this years play alone.

R Lee talks like a man who has been off the tour since the 90's. Bitter.

harpsman Registered User
#25

Martin567 said:
I agree with the above and just wonder why some people find it so hard to get a bit of balance in these discussions. I've never suggested anything other than that the picks would have been very close. I just can't understand all the abuse he gets, a lot of it ill-informed.

Can anyone look at Paul Casey's form for the last few months and explain why they think it is so much better than Harrington's?


well 3rd and 12th in last two majors for starters.ph missed cut in both

#26

harpsman said:
well 3rd and 7th in last two majors for starters.ph missed cut in both


3rd and 12th no? 5 top 10s this year for Casey. 7 for Harrington.

#27

thelongfellow said:
3rd and 12th no? 5 top 10s this year for Casey. 7 for Harrington.


And all but Casey's 3rd at the Open came before March.

soundsham Registered User
#28

Quickly looked at FEC points and ph is at 57

So he's on next week,any cofirmation


Ok checked elsewhere he's out

harpsman Registered User
#29

thelongfellow said:
And all but Casey's 3rd at the Open came before March.


Joke yes?british open july

MasterKZG Registered User
#30

soundsham said:
Quickly looked at FEC points and ph is at 57

So he's on next week,any cofirmation


Ok checked elsewhere he's out



http://www.pgatour.com/2010/tournaments/r505/09/06/whos-eliminated/index.html

Want to share your thoughts?

Login here to discuss!