i went today to the M 50 roundabout , to see conditions that the Roma are living in and the whole experience was very chilling and harrowing , to be happening in 21st century Ireland.
I got permission , and made a small donation , but it really was harrowing, and the sense of danger of kids begging/playing around a dangerous roundabout , needs to be documented IMO, without getting into a political / social debate on photography forum.
As regards photography i prefer photo 1 , but maybe photo 2 highlights the madness of the whole thing.
There a few more on
Great shots first especially,watching the news the other night was thinking the conditions were like refugee camps.
byjaysais is that a man with a scarf on his head?
Tis no woman.
It's important to photograph the people, but I feel they lack context. Portraits with more description in the background about their environment and situation, or a broader array of photos in different locations, reflecting the whole context would have strengthened the photos.
Top marks on engaging them, indeed. Though, I often feel uneasy about photojournalism: in particular, reproducing photos without an adequate caption and permission from the subjects (though this second one is not always possible).
i did get permission, but the whole scenario was crazy , the traffic was whizzing past (this is the M50) , kids running around , even getting my balance was dificult due to slippy surface (mud) , i can only say it was bedlam , and pure 3rd world in our capital .
Nice shots, I would feel that if you had somehow shown the people and in the background or to the side a feeling on speed in the traffic you would get more of a feeling of danger (without putting yourself in the firing line). Fair play to you for doing it, I would have used my bigma from Ballymun!!
Strange that you should put the pictures of Shamrock Rovers' stadium, in with your Roma pictures. I know Rovers are homeless, but Bohs are known as the Gypsies!
Might be a safer place for them to camp though.
Also might move the process of getting it finished along.
Sort of a new version of the old "if I dont get planning permision I'll turn it into a halting site" threat
Some good stuff there Baz, i agree with the suggestions that it may have been a little bit more sympathetic towards the Roma's there if you had got something of a background or their surroundings.
But as a portrait the "look and the Stares" really works for me.
Again, well done on having both the Balls and the get up and go, to go and take these shots.
I only heard about this yesterday. You wouldn't believe the mortality and morbidity rate for Traveller children, Irish and otherwise. Oooo I could rant...
Fair play to you Barry! I would never have the balls (figurative speaking of course) to do that. How did they react when you asked them? I suppose if they've been in the media the last while that made it a bit easier?
And were you ON the M50??
I would like to have got the background in , but i can't emphasise the chaos of the scenario , cars liieraly whizzing past , children pleading at my feet , me tring to speak to the men with little English -- and trying to keep my balance on the mud , an eye on my illegally parked car , and another hand over my wallet , with no press backup
I witnessed something similar about 10 years ago in Morocco ... but happening today in Dublin ?
No it must have been nuts, and you did get some interesting (for want of a better word) pictures out of it, i take my hat off to you.
how did they react to you asking to take pictures?
Are these the families who were deported yesterday?
Three words: "Entirely" "Their" "Choice".