Boards.ie

overshoot · 26-04-2011, 16:47

i want to try to make this a constructive section... (hopefully) and not slagging. basically trying to point out poor route choices

my 2 points,
dublin-donegal bus(route30), bus aras, airport (no problem here, i know its getting bums on seats) but after... the last day i was on it, it went back to the m50 and then the n2 to ashbourne, rathoath and Navan...(navan is the next stop after the airport) why can't it take the fastest route, m50-m3, it would cut half a hour from journey time over 4hr 20) (this part i feel is easily fixed and cannot understand why they use the current route)

i also cannot understand why the cavan (109) bus cannot pick people up between navan, kells, virginia for the much longer donegal route and allow the donegal bus go direct to cavan (from the airport) on the m3. im sure with a bit of effort it could be timed to get to cavan 15-20mins before the donegal bus, which also takes a break in cavan... thus allowing for delays.

i do also realise that the 30bus is faster than 109 and many people in navan, kells etc try to get the 30 rather than the 109 so the last point is more of a wish. but i do feel it could be done fridays/sundays for the busy weekly commuter buses (as in student, and people who work in dublin, go home weekends)

Fo Real · 26-04-2011, 17:28

Bus Éireann cannot operate on the M3 as they don't have a licence. There are enough private competitors on intercity routes, with superior services, that BÉ isn't needed anymore. There is talk in the news about the selling of state owned companies. BÉ should be the first to go imo.

overshoot · 26-04-2011, 17:46

was just about to delete this seen as i found a similar one... not sure how so mods feel free to close.
re fo real: there is no competition on the south donegal/dublin route. mcGeehans offered the only competition and they either joined or were bought by bus eireann

candy19 · 26-04-2011, 20:47

Thanks for bringing up this topic!

I have used this service for the past four years or so mainly on a weekly basis, now I'm glad to say it's more like every six weeks due to the reason OP has brought up!

I as well as many of my friends who would have also travelled as frequently as myself complained on numerous ocassions to Bus Eireann inspectors in both Dublin and in Donegal about the current route.

The motorway opened in June of last year and as of yet they still havn't followed up on the 'authorisation' that they need to use the Motorway!

At the minute, they are timing the new route, which is supposed to operate as normal until you get to Virginia and then onto the motorway, take the slip road into Kells, then back out onto the motorway.

After this, they are planning to go back into Navan to go over Kentstown, to go to Dublin airport.

This is in no way going to shorten the Journey time for passangers! I myself have suggested to the inspectors to pull back the 109A service to Cavan Town as this is what is primarily holding up our journey.

From what I see, if Bus Eireann are willing to pay the toll charges why not make the most of using the motorway.

If the 109 and 109A ran from Cavan Town there would be no reason for the 30 to stop in Cavan except for the 10/15 min break which the driver has to take.

Also, regarding the airport there is no need for the 30 to divert back into Kentstown, there is a road as you come in before Blanchardsown it takes you straight to the airport in ten mins!!

Its about time Bus Eireann got their act together and listened to there customers!!

Vic_08 · 26-04-2011, 21:33

Quote:

Originally Posted by candy19

Thanks for bringing up this topic!

I have used this service for the past four years or so mainly on a weekly basis, now I'm glad to say it's more like every six weeks due to the reason OP has brought up!

I as well as many of my friends who would have also travelled as frequently as myself complained on numerous ocassions to Bus Eireann inspectors in both Dublin and in Donegal about the current route.

The motorway opened in June of last year and as of yet they still havn't followed up on the 'authorisation' that they need to use the Motorway!

At the minute, they are timing the new route, which is supposed to operate as normal until you get to Virginia and then onto the motorway, take the slip road into Kells, then back out onto the motorway.

After this, they are planning to go back into Navan to go over Kentstown, to go to Dublin airport.

This is in no way going to shorten the Journey time for passangers! I myself have suggested to the inspectors to pull back the 109A service to Cavan Town as this is what is primarily holding up our journey.

From what I see, if Bus Eireann are willing to pay the toll charges why not make the most of using the motorway.

If the 109 and 109A ran from Cavan Town there would be no reason for the 30 to stop in Cavan except for the 10/15 min break which the driver has to take.

Also, regarding the airport there is no need for the 30 to divert back into Kentstown, there is a road as you come in before Blanchardsown it takes you straight to the airport in ten mins!!

Its about time Bus Eireann got their act together and listened to there customers!!

From Dublin Airport to Navan the current route taken via the N2 and Kentstown is about as quick as any other. M50-N3 (which would be the route I'd take as it would be more comfortable for the passengers and less prone to random delays) may be 5 minutes quicker but that would be about it. Not sure what road from before Blanch you are talking about, presumably around the industrial complexes north of Blanch and straight across Kilshane cross. These are crap roads, full of HGVs and I guarantee you it is quicker to Navan from Kilshane via the N2 than doing this, at least in a bus.

Regarding using the M3 in full I agree with you completely, all the route 30 services should be non-stop from Cavan or Virginia at least. Using the M3 and serving Navan and Kells is pointless, any time saved on the motorway is lost on the longer journey and countless roundabouts used to get in and out of the towns.

To be honest complaining to the inspectors and drivers about all this is pointless, it is the senior management making these decisions and they do not even bother to consult with us lowly drivers before changing theese timetables, nor do they bother to get a bus out and time these routes either which leads to the almost inevitable reality that the new improved timetables are even worse than the old ones with wildly inaccurate running times meaning buses are unable to keep time on some routes and running early meaning sitting around at certain points for no good reason.

If you really want to complain about this don't bother with the ground staff, most of us who still give a damn are as annoyed by the stupid routes and timetables as you are but we have no say in the matter. Go write a letter to the senior management as these are the people responsible for the timetables. I doubt it would do much good TBH as I believe these people are working to an agenda that has little to do with actually providing the best service possible to our customers but it is still more likely to get your opinion to thise who make these decisions than ranting at powerless inspectors.

Stonewolf · 26-04-2011, 21:50

I got on that bus once, I thought it was the stupidest route possible and was incensed when I got to my destination.

Going in through every 2 bit village on the way, then cutting across to the N2 from Navan and then leaving the N2 to take back roads around the airport.

Vic_08 · 26-04-2011, 22:02

Quote:

Originally Posted by Stonewolf

I got on that bus once, I thought it was the stupidest route possible and was incensed when I got to my destination.

Going in through every 2 bit village on the way, then cutting across to the N2 from Navan and then leaving the N2 to take back roads around the airport.

Before the M3 opened the route took pretty much the quickest most direct route from Dublin Airport at least. It is only with the opening of the M3 there is an opportunity to speed it up by bypassing Navan and Kells.

lxflyer · 27-04-2011, 09:35

Quote:

Originally Posted by candy19

Thanks for bringing up this topic!

I have used this service for the past four years or so mainly on a weekly basis, now I'm glad to say it's more like every six weeks due to the reason OP has brought up!

I as well as many of my friends who would have also travelled as frequently as myself complained on numerous ocassions to Bus Eireann inspectors in both Dublin and in Donegal about the current route.

The motorway opened in June of last year and as of yet they still havn't followed up on the 'authorisation' that they need to use the Motorway!

At the minute, they are timing the new route, which is supposed to operate as normal until you get to Virginia and then onto the motorway, take the slip road into Kells, then back out onto the motorway.

After this, they are planning to go back into Navan to go over Kentstown, to go to Dublin airport.

This is in no way going to shorten the Journey time for passangers! I myself have suggested to the inspectors to pull back the 109A service to Cavan Town as this is what is primarily holding up our journey.

From what I see, if Bus Eireann are willing to pay the toll charges why not make the most of using the motorway.

If the 109 and 109A ran from Cavan Town there would be no reason for the 30 to stop in Cavan except for the 10/15 min break which the driver has to take.

Also, regarding the airport there is no need for the 30 to divert back into Kentstown, there is a road as you come in before Blanchardsown it takes you straight to the airport in ten mins!!

Its about time Bus Eireann got their act together and listened to there customers!!

How do you know that they have not followed it up?

There was (according to the CEO of the NTA) a huge backlog of licence/route applications when they took it over from the Department of Transport who sat on them.

If a private operator has had a licence application approved then there is nothing BE can do about that. That may be the case, and the private operator could be sourcing vehicles/staff etc to operate the service (I don't know), but if it is I am sure that we will find out shortly.

overshoot · 27-04-2011, 12:27

Quote:

Originally Posted by lxflyer

If a private operator has had a licence application approved then there is nothing BE can do about that. That may be the case, and the private operator could be sourcing vehicles/staff etc to operate the service (I don't know), but if it is I am sure that we will find out shortly.

the only 'private' operator is mcGeehans who are joined to bus eireann, they run a shortened 30 route on a daily basis between cavan & enniskillen (or something along that line) these buses could be used on the m3 for the full route (at least for a few services) and bus eireann can put their full buses on the shortened route. straight swap and suddenly journey is down by a hour.

someone said about the toll charges it 2e (4e with both toll booths) for a bus, by the time you pay the driver/diesel for running the senic route, its probably cheaper for the m3

lxflyer · 27-04-2011, 12:35

Quote:

Originally Posted by overshoot

the only 'private' operator is mcGeehans who are joined to bus eireann, they run a shortened 30 route on a daily basis between cavan & enniskillen (or something along that line) these buses could be used on the m3 for the full route (at least for a few services) and bus eireann can put their full buses on the shortened route. straight swap and suddenly journey is down by a hour.

someone said about the toll charges it 2e (4e with both toll booths) for a bus, by the time you pay the driver/diesel for running the senic route, its probably cheaper for the m3

It's mentioned elsewhere on boards that a different private operator holds a licence to operate along the M3 - who that is but I don't know. They have yet to start operating either way.

overshoot · 27-04-2011, 12:59

there are no doubt operators from cavan etc, but there are none independant of BE from south donegal. unless feda o'donnell is going to expand on his galway route (highly unlikely) or donegal coaches their letterkenny route. There are no other private operators operating a public bus service in south donegal

lxflyer · 27-04-2011, 14:14

Quote:

Originally Posted by overshoot

there are no doubt operators from cavan etc, but there are none independant of BE from south donegal. unless feda o'donnell is going to expand on his galway route (highly unlikely) or donegal coaches their letterkenny route. There are no other private operators operating a public bus service in south donegal

We don't know whether licences have been awarded or not - there may have been licences issued to private operators along the M3 which they have not yet started. If that is the case, then BE are precluded from operating along the M3 irrespective of whether a private firm has started operating yet or not.

gazzer · 27-04-2011, 16:44

Im still baffled as to how, almost one year after the M3 opened there is still no public transport from Cavan to Dublin using it. It beggars belief.

Last Wednesday morning I left my house in Cavan at 8am and I was on the quays in Dublin City Centre at 9.25am yet to do the same journey by bus takes well over 2 hours due to the bus having to stop in Navan and pass through Clonee.

mgmt · 27-04-2011, 17:37

Quote:

Originally Posted by gazzer

Im still baffled as to how, almost one year after the M3 opened there is still no public transport from Cavan to Dublin using it. It beggars belief.

Last Wednesday morning I left my house in Cavan at 8am and I was on the quays in Dublin City Centre at 9.25am yet to do the same journey by bus takes well over 2 hours due to the bus having to stop in Navan and pass through Clonee.

It's focked up alright. Perhaps it might change soon (don't hold your breath):

Quote:

Bus Éireann
Further to the above, changes to services on this corridor will be implemented in approx 6 weeks. Full details will be posted on our website nearer that time.

Thanks

about a week ago
http://www.facebook.com/topic.php?ui...05&topic=14403

lxflyer · 27-04-2011, 17:50

That page just about sums up the problems that all operators had with the Department of Transport who just had no concept of how services should be operated.

I do believe that the NTA are taking a far more realistic approach with many contentious routes being approved in recent weeks, so hopefully we will see some results soon on this corridor.

26-04-2011, 16:47	#1
overshoot Registered User Join Date: Jan 2011 Posts: 1,229 Adverts \| Friends	Bus Éireann routes (general) i want to try to make this a constructive section... (hopefully) and not slagging. basically trying to point out poor route choices my 2 points, dublin-donegal bus(route30), bus aras, airport (no problem here, i know its getting bums on seats) but after... the last day i was on it, it went back to the m50 and then the n2 to ashbourne, rathoath and Navan...(navan is the next stop after the airport) why can't it take the fastest route, m50-m3, it would cut half a hour from journey time over 4hr 20) (this part i feel is easily fixed and cannot understand why they use the current route) i also cannot understand why the cavan (109) bus cannot pick people up between navan, kells, virginia for the much longer donegal route and allow the donegal bus go direct to cavan (from the airport) on the m3. im sure with a bit of effort it could be timed to get to cavan 15-20mins before the donegal bus, which also takes a break in cavan... thus allowing for delays. i do also realise that the 30bus is faster than 109 and many people in navan, kells etc try to get the 30 rather than the 109 so the last point is more of a wish. but i do feel it could be done fridays/sundays for the busy weekly commuter buses (as in student, and people who work in dublin, go home weekends)

Thread Tools	Search this Thread
Show Printable Version Email this Page	Search this Thread: Advanced Search

26-04-2011, 17:28	#2
Fo Real Banned Join Date: Sep 2009 Posts: 456 Adverts \| Friends	Bus Éireann cannot operate on the M3 as they don't have a licence. There are enough private competitors on intercity routes, with superior services, that BÉ isn't needed anymore. There is talk in the news about the selling of state owned companies. BÉ should be the first to go imo.

26-04-2011, 17:46	#3
overshoot Registered User Join Date: Jan 2011 Posts: 1,229 Adverts \| Friends	was just about to delete this seen as i found a similar one... not sure how so mods feel free to close. re fo real: there is no competition on the south donegal/dublin route. mcGeehans offered the only competition and they either joined or were bought by bus eireann

26-04-2011, 20:47	#4
candy19 Registered User Join Date: Feb 2009 Location: Dublin 6W Posts: 297 Adverts \| Friends	Thanks for bringing up this topic! I have used this service for the past four years or so mainly on a weekly basis, now I'm glad to say it's more like every six weeks due to the reason OP has brought up! I as well as many of my friends who would have also travelled as frequently as myself complained on numerous ocassions to Bus Eireann inspectors in both Dublin and in Donegal about the current route. The motorway opened in June of last year and as of yet they still havn't followed up on the 'authorisation' that they need to use the Motorway! At the minute, they are timing the new route, which is supposed to operate as normal until you get to Virginia and then onto the motorway, take the slip road into Kells, then back out onto the motorway. After this, they are planning to go back into Navan to go over Kentstown, to go to Dublin airport. This is in no way going to shorten the Journey time for passangers! I myself have suggested to the inspectors to pull back the 109A service to Cavan Town as this is what is primarily holding up our journey. From what I see, if Bus Eireann are willing to pay the toll charges why not make the most of using the motorway. If the 109 and 109A ran from Cavan Town there would be no reason for the 30 to stop in Cavan except for the 10/15 min break which the driver has to take. Also, regarding the airport there is no need for the 30 to divert back into Kentstown, there is a road as you come in before Blanchardsown it takes you straight to the airport in ten mins!! Its about time Bus Eireann got their act together and listened to there customers!!

26-04-2011, 21:50	#6
Stonewolf Registered User Join Date: Feb 2007 Location: Dublin Posts: 1,056 Adverts \| Friends	I got on that bus once, I thought it was the stupidest route possible and was incensed when I got to my destination. Going in through every 2 bit village on the way, then cutting across to the N2 from Navan and then leaving the N2 to take back roads around the airport.

27-04-2011, 12:59	#11
overshoot Registered User Join Date: Jan 2011 Posts: 1,229 Adverts \| Friends	there are no doubt operators from cavan etc, but there are none independant of BE from south donegal. unless feda o'donnell is going to expand on his galway route (highly unlikely) or donegal coaches their letterkenny route. There are no other private operators operating a public bus service in south donegal

27-04-2011, 16:44	#13
gazzer Registered User Join Date: Feb 2003 Posts: 2,380 Adverts \| Friends	Im still baffled as to how, almost one year after the M3 opened there is still no public transport from Cavan to Dublin using it. It beggars belief. Last Wednesday morning I left my house in Cavan at 8am and I was on the quays in Dublin City Centre at 9.25am yet to do the same journey by bus takes well over 2 hours due to the bus having to stop in Navan and pass through Clonee.

27-04-2011, 17:50	#15
lxflyer Registered User Join Date: Jan 2011 Posts: 3,769 Adverts \| Friends	That page just about sums up the problems that all operators had with the Department of Transport who just had no concept of how services should be operated. I do believe that the NTA are taking a far more realistic approach with many contentious routes being approved in recent weeks, so hopefully we will see some results soon on this corridor.