Boards.ie

johnt91 · 08-12-2010, 16:36

Am i the only one who thought Ron's reaction to Hermionie being tortured just wasnt good enough in the film?? i mean in the books he goes crazy screaming "HERMIONIE!!" constantly for about 4 pages but in the films rupert grint pathetically said "we have to do something" in an almost conversational tone????

didnt really think ron's anguish was portrayed well enough??

not doubting rupert's acting abilities at all by the way!

gbee · 08-12-2010, 16:40

Quote:

Originally Posted by johnt91

"HERMIONIE!!" constantly for about 4 pages but in the films rupert grint pathetically said "we have to do something" in an almost conversational tone????!

Don't forget that in the book he was much younger, as he grew into a teenager .... hmmmmm.

THFC · 13-12-2010, 23:58

I seem to be one of the very few people on here that thinks all (barr maybe 1/2) of the actors were woeful. Neither of the main 3 gave an accurate representation of the charcters as they're portrayed in the book. IMO Ron is the worst. In the book he's also slightly cocky and funny, but in the movie he's very timid, and that scene was a very good example of how bad he is. Really hope these movies aren't how they end the HP series.

Smonocco · 25-12-2010, 19:43

I also didn't like the way Harry didn't seem to be too bothered about the fact that his wand was destroyed. It deos after all say in the book: ''Harry took it into his hands as though it was a living thing that had suffered a terrible injury.''

Bob Engineer · 21-01-2011, 06:26

not all part in the book can be realize in movie...

mybe the director think that part not cause big impact...

ManofStraw · 29-01-2011, 23:24

Not to mention that its rare for a movie to be able to portray emotion as effectively as a book. For what its worth I have never felt that the movie's were able to compare to the books mainly due to the extensive editing of the books and the (in parts) fairly shoddy acting

08-12-2010, 16:36	#1
johnt91 Registered User Join Date: Aug 2010 Posts: 141 Adverts \| Friends	Ron's reaction just wasnt good enough! Am i the only one who thought Ron's reaction to Hermionie being tortured just wasnt good enough in the film?? i mean in the books he goes crazy screaming "HERMIONIE!!" constantly for about 4 pages but in the films rupert grint pathetically said "we have to do something" in an almost conversational tone???? didnt really think ron's anguish was portrayed well enough?? not doubting rupert's acting abilities at all by the way!

25-12-2010, 19:43	#4
Smonocco Registered User Join Date: Feb 2010 Location: Co. Kilkenny Posts: 12 Adverts \| Friends	I also didn't like the way Harry didn't seem to be too bothered about the fact that his wand was destroyed. It deos after all say in the book: ''Harry took it into his hands as though it was a living thing that had suffered a terrible injury.'' Last edited by Smonocco; 25-12-2010 at 19:47.

Thread Tools	Search this Thread
Show Printable Version Email this Page	Search this Thread: Advanced Search

13-12-2010, 23:58	#3
THFC Registered User Join Date: Aug 2010 Location: Galway Posts: 4,985 Adverts \| Friends	I seem to be one of the very few people on here that thinks all (barr maybe 1/2) of the actors were woeful. Neither of the main 3 gave an accurate representation of the charcters as they're portrayed in the book. IMO Ron is the worst. In the book he's also slightly cocky and funny, but in the movie he's very timid, and that scene was a very good example of how bad he is. Really hope these movies aren't how they end the HP series.

21-01-2011, 06:26	#5
Bob Engineer Registered User Join Date: Jan 2011 Posts: 11 Adverts \| Friends	not all part in the book can be realize in movie... mybe the director think that part not cause big impact...

29-01-2011, 23:24	#6
ManofStraw Registered User Join Date: Jan 2011 Posts: 226 Adverts \| Friends	Not to mention that its rare for a movie to be able to portray emotion as effectively as a book. For what its worth I have never felt that the movie's were able to compare to the books mainly due to the extensive editing of the books and the (in parts) fairly shoddy acting