Boards.ie

Dodgykeeper · 12-01-2009, 23:00

Myself and others have posted pictures from the recent protests held in Dublin and Cork regarding the situation in Gaza, most of these pictures regardless of the photographers views on the subject were pro Palestine in the content and many of them had slogans prominent which were critical of Israel, now I know that it is ok to post them here but is it ok to submit them into club/national competitions. Could the content offend a judge and you may get marked down, would pictures of this type be appropriate for the boards expo in DCC?

AnCatDubh · 12-01-2009, 23:08

Cabansail may have more insight on the DCC but I would suggest that photography should transcend the political chasm. A great picture is a great picture.

**CabanSail** · 12-01-2009, 23:14

As long as it's suitable for Public Display then it's fine.

The Selection will be done on Photographic Merit & not on Political Content.

If you have a good Documentary Photograph then it should do well in competition.

soccerc · 12-01-2009, 23:14

A picture is a picture, a captured moment in time that may or may not reflect a particular personal view of an event.

Regardless of the subject a good image is a good picture.

shepthedog · 12-01-2009, 23:23

I think a good documentary shot is one of the purest forms of photography... Nothing is faked and its pure emotion...

JMcL · 13-01-2009, 11:18

If a judge marks something down based on some prejudice they have, it's a problem, but there's not a whole hell of a lot you can do about it. Anybody judging competitions should be reasonably impartial, though there's a limit to this - it is all subjective at the end of the day - one judge might hammer an image, another might think it the best thing since sliced bread. In short, I wouldn't let it stop you putting images forward if you think they're strong.

Covey · 13-01-2009, 11:26

The original question is more "PC gone mad stuff".

Where in gods name are you going to get a photo with a pro-Palestine banner and a pro-Isreali one to balance it out.

And would you get out alive

**CabanSail** · 13-01-2009, 12:14

Quote:

Originally Posted by Covey

Where in gods name are you going to get a photo with a pro-Palestine banner and a pro-Isreali one to balance it out.

Layers & Cloning

PaulieC · 13-01-2009, 12:48

while I generally agree with most of what is being said, I doubt you'd get as fair a reaction to your pics if they portrayed pro-Israeli/anti-Palestine images.

Covey · 13-01-2009, 14:41

Quote:

Originally Posted by cambo_gueno

while I generally agree with most of what is being said, I doubt you'd get as fair a reaction to your pics if they portrayed pro-Israeli/anti-Palestine images.

Why ever not

Sure people have an empathy etc. but we/they are judging photos. Surely taking the photo doesn't infer the photographer agreeing with whats happening

If you had excellent shots of the following, would they be marked down because of content?

A Woman being beaten by her husband?
Vultures waiting on a child to die? (That one exists)
A policeman being attacked at Hallowen. (that one exists also)

et al.

T.

trooney · 13-01-2009, 17:15

my guess is that in this part of the world a pro-palastine photo is almost more likely to be received in a better light than a pro-judaism photo. Of course political bias should def be put aside in either case, but people being people...

12-01-2009, 23:00	#1
Dodgykeeper Registered User Join Date: Jan 2006 Location: Dublin Posts: 1,380 Adverts \| Friends	Contentious Pictures Myself and others have posted pictures from the recent protests held in Dublin and Cork regarding the situation in Gaza, most of these pictures regardless of the photographers views on the subject were pro Palestine in the content and many of them had slogans prominent which were critical of Israel, now I know that it is ok to post them here but is it ok to submit them into club/national competitions. Could the content offend a judge and you may get marked down, would pictures of this type be appropriate for the boards expo in DCC?

Thread Tools	Search this Thread
Show Printable Version Email this Page	Search this Thread: Advanced Search

12-01-2009, 23:08	#2
AnCatDubh Registered User Join Date: Aug 2007 Location: The Royal County Posts: 5,294 Adverts \| Friends	Cabansail may have more insight on the DCC but I would suggest that photography should transcend the political chasm. A great picture is a great picture.

12-01-2009, 23:14	#3
CabanSail Category Moderator Join Date: Sep 2006 Location: Northern Rivers NSW Australia Posts: 5,286 Adverts \| Friends CMod: Geocaching, Photography, Arts, Arts Mods	As long as it's suitable for Public Display then it's fine. The Selection will be done on Photographic Merit & not on Political Content. If you have a good Documentary Photograph then it should do well in competition.

12-01-2009, 23:14	#4
soccerc Registered User Join Date: Aug 2006 Location: Ardagh, Longford 109m asl Posts: 1,059 Adverts \| Friends	A picture is a picture, a captured moment in time that may or may not reflect a particular personal view of an event. Regardless of the subject a good image is a good picture.

12-01-2009, 23:23	#5
shepthedog Registered User Join Date: Jun 2003 Posts: 1,671 Adverts \| Friends	I think a good documentary shot is one of the purest forms of photography... Nothing is faked and its pure emotion...

13-01-2009, 11:18	#6
JMcL Registered User Join Date: Jan 2004 Posts: 927 Adverts \| Friends	If a judge marks something down based on some prejudice they have, it's a problem, but there's not a whole hell of a lot you can do about it. Anybody judging competitions should be reasonably impartial, though there's a limit to this - it is all subjective at the end of the day - one judge might hammer an image, another might think it the best thing since sliced bread. In short, I wouldn't let it stop you putting images forward if you think they're strong.

13-01-2009, 11:26	#7
Covey Registered User Join Date: Sep 2006 Location: Dublin Posts: 2,348 Adverts \| Friends	The original question is more "PC gone mad stuff". Where in gods name are you going to get a photo with a pro-Palestine banner and a pro-Isreali one to balance it out. And would you get out alive

13-01-2009, 12:48	#9
PaulieC Registered User Join Date: Sep 2005 Location: Irishtown Posts: 3,586 Adverts \| Friends	while I generally agree with most of what is being said, I doubt you'd get as fair a reaction to your pics if they portrayed pro-Israeli/anti-Palestine images.

13-01-2009, 17:15	#11
trooney Registered User Join Date: Oct 2006 Location: Somewhere not the same Posts: 1,234 Adverts \| Friends	my guess is that in this part of the world a pro-palastine photo is almost more likely to be received in a better light than a pro-judaism photo. Of course political bias should def be put aside in either case, but people being people...