Boards.ie

Ziegfeldgirl27 · 28-07-2012, 17:46

Has anyone on here read it?

I first read it when I was about 17, introduced to it plainly as a fan of the 1939 movie. It took me about 6 weeks to read and I remember being absolutely captivated. So I picked it up yesterday, I'm only about 150 pages in but I honestly think its a masterpiece. It almost reminds me of the hysteria surrounding Harry potter when you watch the footage of the movie premiere. Can you imagine seeing this book come to life for the first time?? It must have been astounding!

cuilteanna · 29-07-2012, 15:05

It's one of the few hardback books I still own (wherever it's disappeared to - dust jacket long gone). My aunt gave it to me at age 12 and I read it over and over again. The movie never quite lived up to the book for me though.

Rosy Posy · 30-07-2012, 11:38

I LOVED this book, I think I've read it three times and will definitely read it again. There is a really great description of the hype that surrounded the book and the movie at the time that it was released in one of Rebecca Wells' Ya-Ya Sisterhood books, it might be the original Divine Secrets of the Ya-Ya Sisterhood. I was a bit disappointed that the film cut out her children by the first two husbands and made her not as much of a hard-as$ b1tch. I love Melanie's birth scene when the yankee's are coming, and the descriptions of the clothes. Also find all the weird stuff about concealing pregnancy fascinating.

Ziegfeldgirl27 · 30-07-2012, 18:55

I remember reading it when I was 17, during Melanie's birth she described so vividly the sweltering heat, I actually felt like I was burning up myself just reading it! I had never read anything like it before.
I'd love to go to the Margaret Mitchell house in Atlanta!

The movie is in my top three films of all time, but even I have to agree that it pales in comparison to the book. But they still did an amazing job and it was probably with good reason they cut out wade and Ella. It mightn't have flowed as well.

dark crystal · 31-07-2012, 16:56

Although Gone With The Wind is my favourite film of all time, I've never read the book. I must buy a copy soon.

Strangely enough though, I'm halfway through reading the sequel 'Scarlet'. Can't say the story is anywhere near as gripping as the Gone With The Wind, but I love the characters so much, I'll stick with it anyway.

Has anyone else read Scarlet and if so, what did you think of it?

cuilteanna · 01-08-2012, 16:39

No, I never read either of the sequels (there was another I think titled "Rhett Butler's People"). I didn't hear many good reviews of either, but then the original is a difficult book to live up to IMO.

28-07-2012, 17:46	#1
Ziegfeldgirl27 Registered User Join Date: Jun 2012 Posts: 530 Adverts \| Friends	Re-reading gone with the wind Has anyone on here read it? I first read it when I was about 17, introduced to it plainly as a fan of the 1939 movie. It took me about 6 weeks to read and I remember being absolutely captivated. So I picked it up yesterday, I'm only about 150 pages in but I honestly think its a masterpiece. It almost reminds me of the hysteria surrounding Harry potter when you watch the footage of the movie premiere. Can you imagine seeing this book come to life for the first time?? It must have been astounding!

Thread Tools	Search this Thread
Show Printable Version Email this Page	Search this Thread: Advanced Search

29-07-2012, 15:05	#2
cuilteanna Registered User Join Date: Jun 2012 Posts: 59 Adverts \| Friends	It's one of the few hardback books I still own (wherever it's disappeared to - dust jacket long gone). My aunt gave it to me at age 12 and I read it over and over again. The movie never quite lived up to the book for me though.

30-07-2012, 11:38	#3
Rosy Posy Registered User Join Date: Sep 2009 Posts: 609 Adverts \| Friends	I LOVED this book, I think I've read it three times and will definitely read it again. There is a really great description of the hype that surrounded the book and the movie at the time that it was released in one of Rebecca Wells' Ya-Ya Sisterhood books, it might be the original Divine Secrets of the Ya-Ya Sisterhood. I was a bit disappointed that the film cut out her children by the first two husbands and made her not as much of a hard-as$ b1tch. I love Melanie's birth scene when the yankee's are coming, and the descriptions of the clothes. Also find all the weird stuff about concealing pregnancy fascinating.

30-07-2012, 18:55	#4
Ziegfeldgirl27 Registered User Join Date: Jun 2012 Posts: 530 Adverts \| Friends	I remember reading it when I was 17, during Melanie's birth she described so vividly the sweltering heat, I actually felt like I was burning up myself just reading it! I had never read anything like it before. I'd love to go to the Margaret Mitchell house in Atlanta! The movie is in my top three films of all time, but even I have to agree that it pales in comparison to the book. But they still did an amazing job and it was probably with good reason they cut out wade and Ella. It mightn't have flowed as well.

31-07-2012, 16:56	#5
dark crystal Registered User Join Date: Dec 2009 Posts: 3,413 Adverts \| Friends	Although Gone With The Wind is my favourite film of all time, I've never read the book. I must buy a copy soon. Strangely enough though, I'm halfway through reading the sequel 'Scarlet'. Can't say the story is anywhere near as gripping as the Gone With The Wind, but I love the characters so much, I'll stick with it anyway. Has anyone else read Scarlet and if so, what did you think of it?

01-08-2012, 16:39	#6
cuilteanna Registered User Join Date: Jun 2012 Posts: 59 Adverts \| Friends	No, I never read either of the sequels (there was another I think titled "Rhett Butler's People"). I didn't hear many good reviews of either, but then the original is a difficult book to live up to IMO.