I can't agree at all with the over the top criticism of Premierview. It is a fine site that I have enjoyed reading for several years. Best of luck to Talk Hurling, but my advice is to do your own thing and stop looking back to Premierview and its faults as you see them. One more GAA site can only be good.
Id agree with many of your sentiments and I used to love to post on Premierview as much as anyone but for me to be just banned from the site without warning or feedback of some sort was both cowardly and despicable.
When you behave in that manner and get drunk on power like that the chickens eventually come home to roost. I do hope if they do return that the operators will behave with a bit of maturity. I believe #talkhurling will be a success and will have learned many lessons from premierview's demise and what caused it