Boards.ie

deisedude · 30-05-2012, 20:54

Quote:

Originally Posted by JaMarcus Hustle

Why?

I think he means most people wouldn't know enough about college ball to make a credible list

JaMarcus Hustle · 30-05-2012, 20:57

Quote:

Originally Posted by deisedude

I think he means most people wouldn't know enough about college ball to make a credible list

Which is why I wanted to see what interest there was first before doing anything.

**frostie500** · 30-05-2012, 22:02

Quote:

Originally Posted by JaMarcus Hustle

Which is why I wanted to see what interest there was first before doing anything.

Id be interested JaMarcus. If nothing else it would be a great way of increasing some peoples knowledge of the college game

CoachTO · 30-05-2012, 22:51

Quote:

Originally Posted by frostie500

Id be interested JaMarcus. If nothing else it would be a great way of increasing some peoples knowledge of the college game

As would I

HigginsJ · 30-05-2012, 22:56

Quote:

Originally Posted by JaMarcus Hustle

Which is why I wanted to see what interest there was first before doing anything.

I'd giue it a shot.

Start with The Honeybadger & sur the rest will fall into place.

johnmcdnl · 30-05-2012, 23:36

I'd be interested in seeing a top 25-50 poll for college football players... won't be voting because I wouldn't know where to start with college players

Only started watching it last year so ended up spending the first 6-7 weeks learning how the BCS system even worked and learning what teams were who etc while trying to find out who were the actual good teams and whatnot as well... I'll admit straight up that I'd be doing well to be able to name a top 10 list of players for this season but I would still love to see a list of names that I could watch out for next season....

Matt Barkley and the Honeybadger are about all I'll have watched before with a good few other names no doubt popping up that sound familiar...

so if even 5-10 of ye guys that know more than me can make lists out so I have names to look out for based on this forum's recomendations... and would be interesting coming back to see how the guys picked fared.... I'd be assuming a top 25 list should be guys that will be all drafted early on in the NFL draft next season... be interesting to come back to it this time next year and see how accurate the picks were and that...

sure it won't be as in depth or have as many voters as the NFL one but if there are enough of ye to do it I'll be keeping an eye on the results for sure just so I can have a list of guys to watch for myself based on yer recomendations

Ares · 31-05-2012, 00:15

In the college rankngs would you be ranking the best football players or the best players at college football?

spiralism · 31-05-2012, 00:54

List v actual:

1. Aaron Rodgers (1)
2. Tom Brady (2)
3. Peyton Manning (8)
4. Adrian Peterson (6)
5. Megatron (3)
6. Jared Allen (10)
7. Patrick Willis (7)
8. Drew Brees (4)
9. James Harrison (44)
10. Philip Rivers (36)
11. Eli Manning (14)
12. Ed Reed (22)
13. Troy Polamalu (23)
14. Terrell Suggs (20)
15. Justin Smith (25)
16. Nnamdi Asomugha (34)
17. Darrelle Revis(5)
18. Gronk (13)
19. Wes Welker (24)
20. Lawrence Timmons
21. Von Miller (35)
22. Victor Cruz (41)
23. Champ Bailey (52)
24. Clay Matthews (30)
25. Tony Romo (69)

Only i picked Timmons i would have got the set. Pretty happy though, lot of my rankings were close to the actual so pleased enough!

Thread Tools	Search this Thread
Show Printable Version Email this Page	Search this Thread: Advanced Search

30-05-2012, 23:36	#486
johnmcdnl Registered User Join Date: Oct 2009 Posts: 3,034 Adverts \| Friends	I'd be interested in seeing a top 25-50 poll for college football players... won't be voting because I wouldn't know where to start with college players Only started watching it last year so ended up spending the first 6-7 weeks learning how the BCS system even worked and learning what teams were who etc while trying to find out who were the actual good teams and whatnot as well... I'll admit straight up that I'd be doing well to be able to name a top 10 list of players for this season but I would still love to see a list of names that I could watch out for next season.... Matt Barkley and the Honeybadger are about all I'll have watched before with a good few other names no doubt popping up that sound familiar... so if even 5-10 of ye guys that know more than me can make lists out so I have names to look out for based on this forum's recomendations... and would be interesting coming back to see how the guys picked fared.... I'd be assuming a top 25 list should be guys that will be all drafted early on in the NFL draft next season... be interesting to come back to it this time next year and see how accurate the picks were and that... sure it won't be as in depth or have as many voters as the NFL one but if there are enough of ye to do it I'll be keeping an eye on the results for sure just so I can have a list of guys to watch for myself based on yer recomendations

31-05-2012, 00:15	#487
Ares Banned Join Date: Apr 2012 Posts: 385 Adverts \| Friends	In the college rankngs would you be ranking the best football players or the best players at college football?

31-05-2012, 00:54	#488
spiralism Registered User Join Date: Sep 2010 Location: Galway Posts: 4,106 Adverts \| Friends	List v actual: 1. Aaron Rodgers (1) 2. Tom Brady (2) 3. Peyton Manning (8) 4. Adrian Peterson (6) 5. Megatron (3) 6. Jared Allen (10) 7. Patrick Willis (7) 8. Drew Brees (4) 9. James Harrison (44) 10. Philip Rivers (36) 11. Eli Manning (14) 12. Ed Reed (22) 13. Troy Polamalu (23) 14. Terrell Suggs (20) 15. Justin Smith (25) 16. Nnamdi Asomugha (34) 17. Darrelle Revis(5) 18. Gronk (13) 19. Wes Welker (24) 20. Lawrence Timmons 21. Von Miller (35) 22. Victor Cruz (41) 23. Champ Bailey (52) 24. Clay Matthews (30) 25. Tony Romo (69) Only i picked Timmons i would have got the set. Pretty happy though, lot of my rankings were close to the actual so pleased enough!