Boards.ie

blue5000 · 15-07-2010, 23:40

Does anybody know if it's possible to change supervisor? I'm trying to do a masters in research, I'd prefer not to say where. I've had a bad working relationship with my supervisor from the beginning and it has made life very difficult to put it mildly.

I'm at the stage where I'm ready to walk away from it, the college have told me if I do this I will not be able to do a masters again, is this true?

Any advice please

TJJP · 15-07-2010, 23:54

It should be a most uncomplicated process. All higher education institutions should now have post-graduate committees to sort such issues out. Sometime people just don’t get on. The responsibility is with the institution, not you or the supervisor (but you do of course have a part to play). Contact the head of department, put it plainly and rationally, but carefully and organise for a transfer.

brianthebard · 16-07-2010, 11:25

Would agree with TJJP, but considering what the college said you I would be careful who you contact about the switch. I don't think they are correct at all, you would have to pay fees if you started a new masters but you wouldn't be prevented from doing it. If there is a lecturer that you've gotten on with in the past or can talk to they might be a good starting point to figure out what the procedure is in your college rather than going straight to the head of the dept, who may or may not be sympathetic to your case.

**convert** · 18-07-2010, 23:28

I know at least one person who has changed supervisor recently. I don't know the reason why they changed, but it was possible.

As for not being able to do another masters having dropped out of one - I've never heard of that and doubt it's entirely accurate. It would be the same as saying that if an undergrad dropped out of one degree that they couldn't do another one at a later date. Perhaps they meant that you couldn't do the same masters course again?

Anyway, does your department have a staff member who is the postgraduate director for the department? Perhaps you could have a chat with them about it and see if you could resolve the issue. Talking to the co-ordinator of your masters would also be a good idea. The head of the department would also be somebody you could contact. Though, as mentioned before, if you get on well with a specific lecturer and you feel they're appraochable, it would be a good idea to have a chat with them and ask their advice.

TJJP · 19-07-2010, 10:07

Quote:

Originally Posted by blue5000

I'm ready to walk away from it, the college have told me if I do this I will not be able to do a masters again, is this true?

Quote:

Originally Posted by convert

As for not being able to do another masters having dropped out of one - I've never heard of that and doubt it's entirely accurate. It would be the same as saying that if an undergrad dropped out of one degree that they couldn't do another one at a later date. Perhaps they meant that you couldn't do the same masters course again?

I'd also doubt this, perhaps you qualify for free fees and this is what the college referred to? If you were to drop-out (not advised btw) you might find yourself landed with full EU fees were you to register for an alternative programme in the future.

blue5000 · 02-04-2012, 00:15

Apologies for resurrecting an old thread ('tis easter) but this never got resolved, I took two years out. The stuff about not being able to do another masters was BS from the supervisor.

Long story, but the college wrote to me recently wanting to know if I intended going back to complete this. The only way, AFAIK to change supervisor was to make a formal complaint, which I didn't do. I just need a few ppl's opinions on what to do, should I try meet with them and see what can be done or should I stay away? Personally I don't want to go back with the same supervisor.

avalon68 · 03-04-2012, 03:25

Quote:

Originally Posted by blue5000

Apologies for resurrecting an old thread ('tis easter) but this never got resolved, I took two years out. The stuff about not being able to do another masters was BS from the supervisor.

Long story, but the college wrote to me recently wanting to know if I intended going back to complete this. The only way, AFAIK to change supervisor was to make a formal complaint, which I didn't do. I just need a few ppl's opinions on what to do, should I try meet with them and see what can be done or should I stay away? Personally I don't want to go back with the same supervisor.

It's hard to drop a supervisor, and the formal complaint route doesn't always work to your benefit and could damage future career prospects (I in no way agree with this, but that's just the way it is unfortunately). How about this suggestion: arrange for a co supervisor, once this person is aboard you can make sure that all three of you are present at meetings - its truly amazing how much some individuals attitudes change when a 3rd party is present. All going well, the new person could become your primary supervisor over time....

stinkle · 03-04-2012, 14:56

I agree with avalon - I had a horrible supervisor who wasn;t so horrible in the presence of a co-supervisor! Nonetheless, is there a postgrad support officer (or similar) in your college? I went to mine wondering about changing supervisor and got a form and brilliant advice immediately. Never actually went through with the change but it helped to know it could be done and that I had the power to request it. Also this didnt involve formal complaints or anything like that.

For what its worth, a mate has added a co-supervisor recently, again no bother there. They managed it by talking to a postgrad rep (a fellow student).

good luck!

15-07-2010, 23:40	#1
blue5000 Registered User Join Date: Jul 2009 Location: Tipperary Posts: 2,798 Adverts \| Friends	Change supervisor? Does anybody know if it's possible to change supervisor? I'm trying to do a masters in research, I'd prefer not to say where. I've had a bad working relationship with my supervisor from the beginning and it has made life very difficult to put it mildly. I'm at the stage where I'm ready to walk away from it, the college have told me if I do this I will not be able to do a masters again, is this true? Any advice please

Thread Tools	Search this Thread
Show Printable Version Email this Page	Search this Thread: Advanced Search

15-07-2010, 23:54	#2
TJJP Registered User Join Date: Dec 2005 Posts: 1,089 Adverts \| Friends	It should be a most uncomplicated process. All higher education institutions should now have post-graduate committees to sort such issues out. Sometime people just don’t get on. The responsibility is with the institution, not you or the supervisor (but you do of course have a part to play). Contact the head of department, put it plainly and rationally, but carefully and organise for a transfer.

16-07-2010, 11:25	#3
brianthebard Registered User Join Date: Oct 2004 Location: Boho Galway, sinking into debt Posts: 15,455 Adverts \| Friends	Would agree with TJJP, but considering what the college said you I would be careful who you contact about the switch. I don't think they are correct at all, you would have to pay fees if you started a new masters but you wouldn't be prevented from doing it. If there is a lecturer that you've gotten on with in the past or can talk to they might be a good starting point to figure out what the procedure is in your college rather than going straight to the head of the dept, who may or may not be sympathetic to your case.

18-07-2010, 23:28	#4
convert Moderator Join Date: Nov 2007 Location: everywhere and anywhere Posts: 5,582 Adverts \| Friends Mod: Equestrian, Greyhound Racing, Horse Racing	I know at least one person who has changed supervisor recently. I don't know the reason why they changed, but it was possible. As for not being able to do another masters having dropped out of one - I've never heard of that and doubt it's entirely accurate. It would be the same as saying that if an undergrad dropped out of one degree that they couldn't do another one at a later date. Perhaps they meant that you couldn't do the same masters course again? Anyway, does your department have a staff member who is the postgraduate director for the department? Perhaps you could have a chat with them about it and see if you could resolve the issue. Talking to the co-ordinator of your masters would also be a good idea. The head of the department would also be somebody you could contact. Though, as mentioned before, if you get on well with a specific lecturer and you feel they're appraochable, it would be a good idea to have a chat with them and ask their advice.

02-04-2012, 00:15	#6
blue5000 Registered User Join Date: Jul 2009 Location: Tipperary Posts: 2,798 Adverts \| Friends	Apologies for resurrecting an old thread ('tis easter) but this never got resolved, I took two years out. The stuff about not being able to do another masters was BS from the supervisor. Long story, but the college wrote to me recently wanting to know if I intended going back to complete this. The only way, AFAIK to change supervisor was to make a formal complaint, which I didn't do. I just need a few ppl's opinions on what to do, should I try meet with them and see what can be done or should I stay away? Personally I don't want to go back with the same supervisor.

03-04-2012, 14:56	#8
stinkle Registered User Join Date: Mar 2010 Posts: 387 Adverts \| Friends	I agree with avalon - I had a horrible supervisor who wasn;t so horrible in the presence of a co-supervisor! Nonetheless, is there a postgrad support officer (or similar) in your college? I went to mine wondering about changing supervisor and got a form and brilliant advice immediately. Never actually went through with the change but it helped to know it could be done and that I had the power to request it. Also this didnt involve formal complaints or anything like that. For what its worth, a mate has added a co-supervisor recently, again no bother there. They managed it by talking to a postgrad rep (a fellow student). good luck!