Advertisement
If you have a new account but are having problems posting or verifying your account, please email us on hello@boards.ie for help. Thanks :)
Hello all! Please ensure that you are posting a new thread or question in the appropriate forum. The Feedback forum is overwhelmed with questions that are having to be moved elsewhere. If you need help to verify your account contact hello@boards.ie

Where to get a food intolerance test?

  • 29-09-2007 7:10pm
    #1
    Registered Users Posts: 617 ✭✭✭Dapos


    Hi,

    I'm looking for somewhere to get a food allergy or food intolerance test (not even sure are they the same thing). Any recommendation around dublin? Also what would they normally cost? 50/60 euro?


«1

Comments

  • Moderators, Society & Culture Moderators Posts: 7,458 Mod ✭✭✭✭CathyMoran


    Go to your GP who will refer you to a specialist who is qualified in this area. It has been years since I got one done. Good luck.


  • Registered Users Posts: 15,290 ✭✭✭✭Supercell


    I had one done a couple of years ago in the Blackrock clinic (blood test), was was over €250 IIRC

    That needed a referral by my GP thugh.

    Waste of time, apparently I'm allergic to pretty much everything except milk, some things more than others. Doctor told me they didnt know what to advise me to eat but to avoid pork and potatoes.
    Funny thing is apparently it didnt show me overly allergic to fish or peanuts that, even if I inhale the smell of, makes my throat start to close over and my breaths become laboured.

    Allergy testing imho isnt very accurate at all.

    Have a weather station?, why not join the Ireland Weather Network - http://irelandweather.eu/



  • Registered Users Posts: 7,659 ✭✭✭Shabadu


    Be careful of the con artists who take a bit of of your hair and sample it. It's nonsense. As far as I know, you'll be asked to exclude groups like dairy & wheat from your diet and keep track of your symptoms.


  • Registered Users Posts: 183 ✭✭I-like-eggs,mmm


    Hey.... I had a food intolerence test done there back in April- was really good.

    The guy took a sample of blood from me, sent it off to be tested( for around 250 foods or so), I got the results in about 2 weeks.

    Then he went through the results, gave the level of intolerence for whatever food I was intolerent to (Milk and Eggs)- and he went through alternatives.

    Felt great anyway when I stayed away from the food he mentioned. He emphasised staying well away from the food when I was under any sort of pressure or stress as the digestive system is more sensitive to these foods at those times.

    The test was around 200Euro. It was an IGg test (IGg tests for intolerences and IGe is for allergies as far as I remember).

    He's based in Rialto and he has a book on the basics of food intolerences, if you're interested?


  • Registered Users Posts: 617 ✭✭✭Dapos


    I am trying to find a place that doesn't use blood samples and isn't as expensive. These tests usually cost around 60 euro i'm told. Holland and Barretts (Nature's Way) do them but they are booked out for a few weeks, wondering is there may other places?


  • Advertisement
  • Registered Users Posts: 617 ✭✭✭Dapos


    Ok i got one done on saturday. It's a place called "Down to Earth" on George's St. 40 Euro. Intolerant to a few things, i'll give it a go for a few weeks and see how i feel. For future reference some of the Nature's Way stores do the test but u would have to book a few weeks in advance, 65 euro with a 20 euro deposit. La Sante in Dun Laoghaire do them too for 40 euro (10 Euro deposit). From wat i gather they all seem a similar test, no blood, no needles.


  • Closed Accounts Posts: 146 ✭✭musicfan


    Has anyone ever had one of these tests done i.e. the ones that don't involve blood or hair samples?

    Are they any good or how accurate are they?

    Any opinions / experiences etc??


  • Registered Users Posts: 429 ✭✭microgirl


    Longfield wrote: »
    I had one done a couple of years ago in the Blackrock clinic (blood test), was was over €250 IIRC

    That needed a referral by my GP thugh.

    Waste of time, apparently I'm allergic to pretty much everything except milk, some things more than others. Doctor told me they didnt know what to advise me to eat but to avoid pork and potatoes.
    Funny thing is apparently it didnt show me overly allergic to fish or peanuts that, even if I inhale the smell of, makes my throat start to close over and my breaths become laboured.

    Allergy testing imho isnt very accurate at all.

    There's a difference between a food intolerance and a genuine allergy, and so there is a difference between the tests done for both. Specifically, different antibodies are involved, and tests geared to pick up one won't pick up the other.

    OP - I can heartily recommend YorkTest (www.yorktext.ie), but be warned you will pay for it. It's €349 or something, but it's a proper, genuine, scientific-based food intolerance test (and as a medical scientist I can confirm that that's not just marketing), not one of these quack rubbish things about ribs of hair, or muscle tone or what have you.

    They test 113 foodstuffs or mixes and the test picked up my known intolerance (diagnosed dairy intolerant at 3yrs) and confirmed one that I was 99% sure I had, but hoped I didn't (yeast) and a couple of more surprising ones (soya and eggs). I also have a few "borderline" foods, that I should limit my intake in.

    Ok, strictly speaking I can't vouch for them to much because I haven't actually taken the steps and made the changes I should have, so I don't know how good removing these from my diet will be, but I suspect very, based on symptoms and, as I said, my knowledge that dairy and yeast have a bad affect on me anyway.

    If you're not 100% certain you have a food intolerance at all, you can get a mini-test done which costs about €29, which basically gives you a yes or no answer. If you test positive for intolerance, you can upgrade to a full test without having to send in a new sample, and they just charge you the remainder. If you test negative, well, you've saved €300 :)

    If you think it might be a true allergy rather than an intolerance, they have a specific allergy test you can get instead.

    I really do recommend checking them out. A good, proper test like that is going to cost money. The ones for €60 aren't going to be worth it at all, IMO. But it's your health and well-being that's in consideration here, and a few hundred quid to change you life right around (provided you make the necessary changes) is, I think, worth it.

    Edited to add: Oooh! Just saw I Like Eggs' reply - yes, that's pretty much exactly what YORKtest do, but that's significantly cheaper. I'd go for that one definitely :D


  • Registered Users Posts: 429 ✭✭microgirl


    Oops! Hadn't realised how old a thread this was. Feel stupid now :D


  • Closed Accounts Posts: 3,243 ✭✭✭kelle


    My mother (RIP) was a Kinesiologist. She used muscle testing to check intolerance to different foods. I was slightly overweight and was almost crippled following a back injury, so I got tested by her and gave up the foods I was found to be intolerant to (wheat, sugar, white potato, tomatoes). She said they were causing weakness of muscles which stopped me recovering from the back injury (having 2 small kids didn't help either!). 2 days after starting my exclusion diet my back pain vanished, and I lost all my baby weight in a few weeks. I have great faith in it, and it doesn't involve needles or body samples. I don't know how much is charged nowadays, but I don't think it's as expensive as the prices quoted above - my mother only charged e35.
    There's more information here about it.


  • Advertisement
  • Closed Accounts Posts: 24 dairec


    Hey.... I had a food intolerence test done there back in April- was really good.

    He's based in Rialto and he has a book on the basics of food intolerences, if you're interested?

    I'm interested. Can you give me his contact details?

    Daire


  • Registered Users Posts: 6 PhilK


    I've just had a test done for our 2 and half year old who was suffering from severe exzema. Our Naturopath suggested

    www.camnutri.com

    who do the same test as York but at nearly half the price.

    He turns out to have intolerance of some really basic stuff (milk, wheat, soya). As we're on a low income any advice out there on how to source cheap alternatives would be very welcome.


  • Registered Users Posts: 465 ✭✭Iristxo


    I think the one that I like eggs mentions can be this one...

    http://martinhealy.goldenpages.ie/ms/ms/martin_healy+allergy_testing_allergists+dublin+ms-90013063+p-2.html

    Which is somehow connected to the clinic in Fitzwilliam Sq, or so it seems


  • Closed Accounts Posts: 1,957 ✭✭✭Euro_Kraut


    People need to be careful about this.

    There is a lot of evidence to suggest the IgG Antibody testing (used by YorkTest amoung others) cannot actually show food intolerance's.

    The UK Advertising Watchdog took YorkTest to take in 2007 for the claims they were making.


    The Australian Authority also cast doubt

    An inquiry of the House of Lords in England also concluded there was no scientific basis to the tests.

    I found some good blogs on this too:

    Myth: You Can Diagnose Food Intolerance or Allergy with an IgG Blood Test

    &

    IgG Tests Are A Waste of Money: House of Lords Committee Hears Evidence, Let's Hope That They Listen

    Its probably a good idea to read through the evidence that currently exists before deciding to spend €250+ on a test.


  • Users Awaiting Email Confirmation Posts: 5,620 ✭✭✭El_Dangeroso


    Euro_Kraut wrote: »
    People need to be careful about this.

    There is a lot of evidence to suggest the IgG Antibody testing (used by YorkTest amoung others) cannot actually show food intolerance's.

    The UK Advertising Watchdog took YorkTest to take in 2007 for the claims they were making.


    The Australian Authority also cast doubt

    An inquiry of the House of Lords in England also concluded there was no scientific basis to the tests.

    I found some good blogs on this too:

    Myth: You Can Diagnose Food Intolerance or Allergy with an IgG Blood Test

    &

    IgG Tests Are A Waste of Money: House of Lords Committee Hears Evidence, Let's Hope That They Listen

    Its probably a good idea to read through the evidence that currently exists before deciding to spend €250+ on a test.

    Completely agreed, a lot of us can have sensitivities that don't show up on these tests at all, never mind the inconvenience of a false-positive result. These kinds of blood tests are notoriously inaccurate. Testing of antibodies in stool is more accurate but still not without problems. It'd be wonderful just to get a blood test and know exactly what foods you should personally avoid, but the science is just not there yet.


  • Registered Users Posts: 522 ✭✭✭ValueSeeker


    Vaga Food Allergy Testing in the Old Bawn Clinic in Tallaght. Run by Alan and Phil Kelly. It's predominantly a sports injury clinic.

    I had no life for 3 years, constantly in and out of hospitals and they were clueless. Went to this place not expecting anything. She hooked me up to the circuit, diagnosed me as wheat intolerant and whatayuno, 3 weeks later, all my physical symptoms were gone.

    I'm going back to her tomorrow as I'm back on wheat and feeling disgusting - I didn't realise feelings of anxiety, depression and brain fog and other mental symptoms can also be symptoms of food intolerance.

    Only 70 euro and no needles


  • Closed Accounts Posts: 2 SineadPh


    Maev Creaven from the Galway Nutrition Centre in Galway tests for food intolerances. www.nutritioncentre.ie There are no needles used.


  • Registered Users Posts: 154 ✭✭teacosy


    Accurate information on the subject of testing for food intolerances and allergies can be read here;

    http://www.bda.uk.com/foodfacts/AllergyTesting.pdf


  • Closed Accounts Posts: 4,754 ✭✭✭oldyouth


    I see there are comments for and against these tests but can I ask if anyone has tried this one through Sam McCauley Chemists

    http://www.buy4now.ie/sammccauley/aspx/shopping.aspx?loc=C&catid=91

    Thanks in advance


  • Registered Users Posts: 293 ✭✭Shmatter


    I don't know about other intolerances, but I'm lactose intolerant, don't know how it happened as I wasn't as a kid, also managed to develop hay fever the same time. I went to my doctor, he told me about the test he could do, but that just keeping a food diary and looking at the results myself is enough. I'd recommend that if you suspect dairy anyway.


  • Advertisement
  • Registered Users Posts: 15 december80


    Dapos wrote: »
    Ok i got one done on saturday. It's a place called "Down to Earth" on George's St. 40 Euro. Intolerant to a few things, i'll give it a go for a few weeks and see how i feel. For future reference some of the Nature's Way stores do the test but u would have to book a few weeks in advance, 65 euro with a 20 euro deposit. La Sante in Dun Laoghaire do them too for 40 euro (10 Euro deposit). From wat i gather they all seem a similar test, no blood, no needles.



    hi just wondering di d you think the test was accurate?


  • Registered Users Posts: 15 december80


    Dapos wrote: »
    Ok i got one done on saturday. It's a place called "Down to Earth" on George's St. 40 Euro. Intolerant to a few things, i'll give it a go for a few weeks and see how i feel. For future reference some of the Nature's Way stores do the test but u would have to book a few weeks in advance, 65 euro with a 20 euro deposit. La Sante in Dun Laoghaire do them too for 40 euro (10 Euro deposit). From wat i gather they all seem a similar test, no blood, no needles.


    Hi i went to the Down to Earth shop yesterday to get an allergy test.
    They said i am allergic to Dairy products and Sugar.
    Did many come up that you were allergic to im not sure whether i believe its true as ive been eating this stuff all my life and ive never had any problems. if you could reply to me that would be great.


  • Posts: 0 [Deleted User]


    december80 wrote: »
    Hi i went to the Down to Earth shop yesterday to get an allergy test.
    They said i am allergic to Dairy products and Sugar.
    Did many come up that you were allergic to im not sure whether i believe its true as ive been eating this stuff all my life and ive never had any problems. if you could reply to me that would be great.

    I've never gone for one of these tests but I saw a pretty believable documentary about the ones done in health food shops (even reputable places like Holland and Barrett) being false and unreliable. This does make sense seeing as if you go through your GP it should be around 200euro. There must be a reason that the one a doctor would trust is about 5 times the cost of some of the health shop ones. There's not much harm in cutting dairy and sugar for a few weeks and seeing if it makes a difference, but these are important food groups and if they've never given you trouble before, I wouldn't trust the test enough to cut them out of your life.


  • Registered Users Posts: 8,842 ✭✭✭Soarer


    Anyone know anywhere in Cork that does the intolerance tests?
    Rang The Melbourne Clinic, and they're not doing it anymore.

    Saw this crowd that do a 200+ food test for £285, which I'd stretch for. But when you go to buy it, it tells you to contact this crowd in Dublin, who charge €255 for a 93 food test.
    Sounds like a rip-off to me!


  • Registered Users Posts: 154 ✭✭teacosy


    The UK allergy association and the British Dietetic Association give some sound advice about the accuracy of commercial allergy tests.

    http://www.allergyuk.org/fs_testing.aspx

    http://www.bda.uk.com/foodfacts/AllergyTesting.pdf


  • Registered Users Posts: 6,394 ✭✭✭Transform


    very very little of all this testing is going to show you or tell you anything that you would not figure out yourself on a simple food elmination diet.

    Cut out all gluten - wow you feel better, drop weight and joints feel less achy!! Did i need a test for that, no. People just love the lab coat effect and the fact that its written on a piece of paper.

    i used to get many of my clients tested for food intolerence and stopped when I sent in two blood samples from myself (same time) and they came back with two different results!

    Now i just get everyone off gluten, exercise more, cut out processed foods, eat more veg, some fruit and plenty of good fats and protein and whatttay know they drop weight, feel better and degenerative conditions clear up significantly.

    Its money you could be spending buying some god healthy food and a big tub of fish oils IMO


  • Registered Users Posts: 119 ✭✭arandale


    Heard discussed on Mid west Radio a test called Nutron, do anyone of you know anything about it.


  • Registered Users Posts: 6,394 ✭✭✭Transform


    arandale wrote: »
    Heard discussed on Mid west Radio a test called Nutron, do anyone of you know anything about it.
    emmm food elimination anyone?


  • Closed Accounts Posts: 7 firetrap8


    I've done the test at bodysmart; they just took a blood sample (very easy and painless) and sent the results to some Food Institute for analysis. result came after a two weeks. I've done the test for 40 food items, there is an option for some 93 foods which is a bit more expensive. some info on this page:

    http://www.bodysmart.ie/food-intolerance-test.html


  • Advertisement
  • Users Awaiting Email Confirmation Posts: 5,620 ✭✭✭El_Dangeroso


    firetrap8 wrote: »
    I've done the test at bodysmart; they just took a blood sample (very easy and painless) and sent the results to some Food Institute for analysis. result came after a two weeks. I've done the test for 40 food items, there is an option for some 93 foods which is a bit more expensive. some info on this page:

    http://www.bodysmart.ie/food-intolerance-test.html

    If anyone wants to send me €135 to send them made up test results with no level of accuracy whatsoever then I'm open for business! I'm now accepting credit cards at Ican'tbelievepeoplestillbelievethiscrap.com.:P


Advertisement