gshaw Registered User
#1

My mum drives a 00 automatic A-Class and the gearbox was making a grinding noise when she changed it so I brought it to the local garage. They advised me that the gearbox is shot and will have to be replaced - cost will be about two and a half thousand to do this. The car is nine years old but it only has 39,000 miles on it. The specialist that I had to call about getting a new gearbox told me that this is a common problem with these type of cars. Just wondering if anyone has had similar problems with their A-Class gearbox. I just think its insane that a gearbox should give out after only 39,000 miles and the cost to fix it is the same as the value of the car. Appreciate any information anyone might have on this - am also writing to the CEO of Mercedes-Benz in Europe to ask him does he have any explanation for such a serious and expensive problem in a car that has been in the family since its manufacture that has very low mileage. Would appreciate any feedback on this issue.

Mr Benevolent Closed Account
#2

What about looking around for a reconditioned autobox?

gshaw Registered User
#3

The garage are going to have a look around and see what they can do, i just think it's bad engineering that the gearbox should even need to be replaced.

Anan1 Registered User
#4

Try changing the fluid and filter first.

gshaw Registered User
#5

They already tried that, the garage told me it's an unfortunate problem to have with the car as it will be expensive to repair but that's it's a common problem with the A-Class

Stevie Dakota Registered User
#6

Let us know what the CEO of Mercedes-Benz says! Seriously though, sounds like you have been unlucky but no manufacturer will step in after 9 years. I would advise getting a second opinion if possible, Conway Transmissions. 8 St Peter's, Walkinstown, Dublin 014502623 have a good reputation and do a lot of dealer work.

Not affiliated.

ronoc Registered User
#7

gshaw said:
Appreciate any information anyone might have on this - am also writing to the CEO of Mercedes-Benz in Europe to ask him does he have any explanation for such a serious and expensive problem in a car that has been in the family since its manufacture that has very low mileage. Would appreciate any feedback on this issue.


Maybe I'm being cynical but I don't think the CEO of Merc is going to bother replying to a letter about a gearbox in a car that is 9 years old and is the cheapest model they make.

1 person has thanked this post
gshaw Registered User
#8

Conway Transmissions is exactly who my local garage referred me to! Spoke to them this morning and the guy was great, took the chassis number of the car and is going to do his best to source something. Only problem will be getting it to him as parents live in Glenageary and no way the car is going to make it to Walkisntown with a broken gear box!! Will be interesting to see what the CEO has to say about this. Am just really disappointed that the brand Mercedes has such a good reputation which is why they bought the car in the first place only to have this happen.

EPM Closed Account
#9

Firstly, dont waste your time with that letter. He will never see it or give a toss for that matter

Try around for a reconditioned gearbox. It should cut the cost of the repair considerably.

gshaw Registered User
#10

ronoc said:
Maybe I'm being cynical but I don't think the CEO of Merc is going to bother replying to a letter about a gearbox in a car that is 9 years old and is the cheapest model they make.


Don't expect to get a reply direct from the CEO but if you are going to manufacture a car and promote it as reliable then you have to stand over it and at least give an explanation when it has a serious defect as this one seems to have.

gshaw Registered User
#11

EPM said:
Firstly, dont waste your time with that letter. He will never see it or give a toss for that matter

Try around for a reconditioned gearbox. It should cut the cost of the repair considerably.


Don't think i'm wasting my time with the letter, it's not an abusive letter by any means. Just explains the problems we're having with the car and asks for feedback from them.

Stevie Dakota Registered User
#12

gshaw said:
Conway Transmissions is exactly who my local garage referred me to! Spoke to them this morning and the guy was great, took the chassis number of the car and is going to do his best to source something. Only problem will be getting it to him as parents live in Glenageary and no way the car is going to make it to Walkisntown with a broken gear box!!


Join the AA, Hibernian Aviva is even cheaper, and call them in a few days. Then get it lifted to Conways. You'll enjoy the cover, post repair, which you may need.

gshaw Registered User
#13

Thanks - car is covered on a Hibernian Aviva policy so may have to call them in a few days when I hear back from Conways about the replacement gear box.

Stevie Dakota Registered User
#14

Good luck, hope it all works out. In the meantime check our some MB forums in the UK, there must be some advice if this is a known problem.

Want to share your thoughts?

Login here to discuss!